The NFL Draft is a treasure hunt for teams looking to find game-changing players without breaking the bank. Edge rushers—players who pressure the quarterback from the defensive line—are critical to a team’s success. Some of the best edge rushers in recent history were picked in later rounds, proving you don’t need a high draft pick to land a star. This article highlights five of the best edge rusher draft steals since 2000, explaining why they were such great finds and how they impacted their teams. Let’s dive into these hidden gems!
What Makes a Draft Steal?
A draft steal happens when a team picks a player later in the draft—typically in the third round or beyond—who performs like a first-round talent. These players often exceed expectations, delivering big plays, stats, and leadership for a fraction of the cost. For edge rushers, key traits like speed, strength, and instincts make them stand out, even if they weren’t early picks.
Why Edge Rushers Matter
Edge rushers are game-changers. They disrupt offenses by sacking quarterbacks, forcing fumbles, and stopping runs. Teams that find these players in later rounds save money and roster spots, allowing them to build stronger teams overall. Let’s look at five edge rushers who were absolute steals in the NFL Draft.
1. T.J. Watt – Pittsburgh Steelers (2017, Round 1, Pick 30)
A Late First-Round Gem
T.J. Watt, selected by the Pittsburgh Steelers in 2017, was the 30th overall pick—technically a first-rounder, but a late one. Many teams passed on him, but Watt quickly proved them wrong. Coming out of Wisconsin, he showed raw talent, and the Steelers saw his potential to become a defensive superstar.
Why He’s a Steal
Watt’s stats are jaw-dropping. By 2025, he’s racked up over 100 career sacks, earning the NFL Defensive Player of the Year award in 2021. His ability to disrupt plays with sacks, forced fumbles, and interceptions makes him a nightmare for quarterbacks. For a late first-round pick, his impact is unmatched, making him a steal.
2. Khalil Mack – Oakland Raiders (2014, Round 1, Pick 5)
A Top Talent at a Bargain
Khalil Mack, drafted by the Oakland Raiders in 2014, was the fifth overall pick. While not a late-round pick, his value comes from how dominant he’s been compared to other top-five selections. From Buffalo University, Mack was a bit of an unknown, but his athleticism made him a safe bet.
Why He’s a Steal
Mack’s versatility sets him apart. He can rush the passer, stop the run, and even drop back in coverage. By 2025, he’s earned multiple All-Pro honors and consistently posts double-digit sacks. His trade to the Chicago Bears and later the Los Angeles Chargers showed his value, as teams were willing to give up big assets for him.
3. Terrell Suggs – Baltimore Ravens (2003, Round 1, Pick 10)
A Defensive Anchor
Terrell Suggs, picked 10th overall by the Baltimore Ravens in 2003, was another first-round steal. Coming from Arizona State, Suggs had raw power and speed, but some teams questioned his consistency. The Ravens took a chance, and it paid off big time.
Why He’s a Steal
Suggs became the heart of Baltimore’s defense. With 139 career sacks by the end of his career, he ranks among the NFL’s all-time greats. His ability to pressure quarterbacks and mentor younger players made him invaluable. For a mid-first-round pick, Suggs delivered elite production for over a decade.
4. George Karlaftis – Kansas City Chiefs (2022, Round 1, Pick 30)
A Rising Star
The Kansas City Chiefs struck gold with George Karlaftis in 2022, selecting him 30th overall. Coming from Purdue, Karlaftis wasn’t a household name, but his work ethic and physicality caught the Chiefs’ attention. He’s quickly become a cornerstone of their defense.
Why He’s a Steal
Karlaftis has shown steady improvement, posting double-digit sacks in recent seasons. His ability to play multiple roles on the defensive line makes him versatile. For a late first-rounder, his contributions to Kansas City’s Super Bowl runs make him a fantastic value pick.
5. Chris Jones – Kansas City Chiefs (2016, Round 2, Pick 37)
A Mid-Round Marvel
Chris Jones, another Chiefs gem, was drafted in the second round in 2016. From Mississippi State, Jones wasn’t a top prospect, but his size and quickness made him intriguing. The Chiefs saw his potential, and he’s since become one of the NFL’s best defensive linemen.
Why He’s a Steal
Jones, while often listed as a defensive tackle, plays edge rusher in certain packages, making him a hybrid star. His 70+ career sacks and constant pressure on quarterbacks have been key to Kansas City’s success. For a second-round pick, his All-Pro honors and Super Bowl contributions are incredible value.
How Teams Find These Steals
Finding draft steals requires smart scouting and a bit of luck. Teams look for players with raw talent, strong work ethics, and the ability to fit their defensive schemes. College performance, athletic testing, and character all play a role. The Chiefs, for example, have a knack for finding edge rushers like Karlaftis and Jones, thanks to their focus on versatile players who can grow into bigger roles.
The Role of Coaching
Great coaching can turn a late-round pick into a star. Coaches help players refine their skills, teaching them techniques to outsmart opponents. For instance, Watt and Suggs benefited from defensive-minded coaches who maximized their strengths.
Conclusion
The NFL Draft is full of surprises, and edge rushers like T.J. Watt, Khalil Mack, Terrell Suggs, George Karlaftis, and Chris Jones prove that you don’t need a top pick to find a game-changer. These players, selected outside the top five or in later rounds, delivered elite performances, helping their teams win games and championships. By finding these steals, teams like the Steelers, Ravens, and Chiefs built dominant defenses without spending high draft picks. As the NFL continues to evolve, smart scouting and coaching will keep uncovering the next generation of edge rusher gems.